Carl offers to buy Paul's magazine subscriptions if he'll let him suck his cock and fuck him. Paul agrees, despite being a virgin and Carl jams his thick cock into his tight hole. Carl reams him out, then Paul tries to return the favor, but he's a newbie. Carl takes it like a pro and then they both cum all over each other's faces and in each other's mouths. They swallow the cum, a dirty, messy finish.